The Differences between Welded and Seamless Tubes

Stainless steel tubing is one of the most helpful metal alloys for manufacturing and fabrication. However, seamless and welded tubing are the two most popular forms. The choice of welded vs. seamless tubes mostly depends on the product’s application requirements. When deciding between the two, remember that the tubing must adhere to the requirements of your project. Next, it must meet the conditions under which you can use the tubing.

Tubing vs. Piping

Although tube and pipe are frequently used synonymously, partly because both have hollow shapes, there are significant differences when deciding whether you need welded or seamless tubing. First, measure the tubes’ outer diameter (OD) and wall thickness. On the other hand, you should also measure a pipe’s internal diameter. In terms of utility, you can use piping typically to carry fluids, liquids, and gases, whereas line pipe suppliers typically employ tubes in structural and aesthetically pleasing applications.

Seamless Tubing Manufacturing

Knowing the difference helps you choose whether seamless or welded tubing suits a specific application. Even the names make it clear how manufacturers make welded and seamless tubing. The definition of a seamless tube is that it has no welded seams. Instead, pipe fabricators use extrusion to create the tubing, drawing from a solid billet of stainless steel and forming it into a hollow shape. First, they heat the billets before shaping them into hollow, oblong circular molds in a piercing mill. Next, the molds are dragged through a mandrel rod and lengthened while still hot. For a seamless tube shape, the mandrel milling procedure doubles the length of the molds. Seamless tube manufacturers further shape the tubes through pilgering, a cold rolling process, or cold drawing.

Welded Tubing Manufacturing

Rolling stainless steel sheets or strips into a tube shape and longitudinally welding the seam results in a welded stainless steel tube. Cold forming and hot forming techniques create welded tubing. Cold forming produces better finishes and closer tolerances than hot forming. The steel tubes produced by each technique are resilient, robust, and corrosion-resistant. The seam might be forgone or processed using cold rolling and forging techniques. The welded tube can also be drawn similarly to seamless tubing for a finer weld seam with superior surface finishes and tighter tolerances.

Choosing Between Welded and Seamless

There are benefits and drawbacks in choosing welded vs. seamless tubes.

Seamless Tubing

By definition, seamless tubing is an entirely homogeneous tube. As a result, the characteristics of seamless pipes and tubes include being more robust, more resistant to corrosion, and able to handle more pressure than welded tubes. As a result, it increases their suitability in demanding situations for vital applications, albeit at a cost.

There is no longitudinal weld seam in a seamless tube. Therefore, a device to press the hole into the billet is needed to produce seamless tubing.

Today, rotary piercing and rolling are the most often used techniques for creating seamless tubing. A conditioned steel round bar is the first step in the process. Next, seamless tube manufacturers heat, perforate, and work on the tubes. Next, they shape the bar to flow around a sharp point for a hollow billet creation.

While they extend the billet roller, they support the tube interior with a mandrel or a plug. Finally, the outside diameter of the steel tube is further rolled to achieve sizing.

Due to the lack of a welded seam, seamless tubing has working pressures 20% higher than welded tubing of the same material and size. As a result, the end users may be concerned if they can see the seam in the welded tubing. Seamless tube manufactured by seamless line pipe suppliers has the added benefit of having higher corrosion resistance due to their low impurity potential. By using seamless tubing, you can prevent flaws and variances in malleability that could be connected to the welded area in welded tubes. In addition, unlike welded tubes, seamless tubes don’t need to have their welds tested for integrity. Therefore, seamless tubing is often more suitable for critical applications.

Benefits

Stronger

Superior corrosion resistance

Higher pressure resistance

Applications

Oil and gas control lines

Chemical injection lines

Below sea safety valves

Chemical processing plant steam and heat trace bundles

Fluid and gas transfer

Welded Tubing

Unlike seamless tubes, the welded tubing begins with rolling a steel coil to the desired gauge thickness. The outcome is a coil of a flat strip. The next step involves cutting the strip according to the width corresponding to the tube size to be produced.

Welded tubing is less expensive than seamless tubing because of the more straightforward manufacturing process to create welded tubing. It is readily available, like seamless tubing in a long and continuous length. Pipe producers can manufacture standard sizes with similar lead times for seamless and welded tubing. The seamless tubing costs can be offset if the required quantity is insufficient in smaller manufacturing runs. Otherwise, manufacturers can customize seamless tubing and deliver them quickly. But the process is costlier.

Line pipe suppliers manufacture the tubes by moving the cut coil through a roller series, and they weld the tube seam in a chemically neutral environment. Next, they forge the welded seam with rolling, and the welded tube is finished with a heat-treating procedure. Next, they smooth down the welded seam and make the edges virtually as invisible as possible by drawing the tubes over mandrels and grinding as necessary.

The cost of welded and drawn tubing can be less expensive than seamless tubing. Also, you can typically obtain the pipes more quickly than seamless tubing because they require less drawing and annealing during the fabrication of a welded and drawn tube (although stocking intermediate-size starting stock for seamless tubing can also reduce this lead time).

Benefits

Cost-efficient

Readily available in long lengths

Fast lead times

Applications

Architectural applications

Hypodermic needles

Automotive industry

Food and beverage industry

Marine industry

Pharmaceutical industry

Conclusion:

Both seamless tubes and welded pipes have their usage and applications. While welded pipes can offer an affordable option in some sectors, investing in high-quality seamless pipes and tubes for some industries is vital. Welded tubes have seams or joint edges, making them weaker than seamless pipes. However, they are good options for low-pressure uses.

On the other hand, seamless pipes and tubes do not have any seams, which makes them stronger and a durable option. As a result, more and more industries are leaning towards using seamless pipes and tubes.

 

Press Release Pedia
Logo
Shopping cart